Moving from California to Idaho? 11 Big Differences You Need to Know First

Considering Idaho? Here’s What You Really Need to Know Before You Move

Are you thinking about leaving California for a fresh start in Idaho? You’re not alone. Thousands of families have packed up in search of more space, lower taxes, and a slower pace of life.

But not everyone stays.

I’m Curtis Chism—a licensed REALTOR® who made the move from sunny San Diego to Boise, Idaho. I now run one of the top relocation real estate businesses in the Treasure Valley, helping Californians like you figure out if Idaho is the right next chapter.

And I’m here to give you the real story: the good, the tough, and everything in between.

Let’s break down 11 big differences you need to know before moving from California to Idaho—and who this move is (and isn’t) for.

1. Population and Density: Idaho Is Way More Spread Out

California’s cities are packed. San Diego County alone has over 3.3 million people. Boise? About 235,000. The entire state of Idaho is still under 2 million people total.

The Treasure Valley (Boise, Meridian, Nampa, Caldwell, Eagle, etc.) has around 900,000 people and is growing fast—but it still feels small compared to LA, the Bay Area, or even Orange County.

If you’re looking for wide-open space and room to breathe, Idaho delivers.

2. Traffic: Yes, It Exists—But It’s Not LA

Traffic in the Treasure Valley is growing—but it’s nothing like California’s gridlock. Boise ranks 25th for traffic congestion in the U.S., compared to LA (#1) and San Diego (#12). Commutes are still manageable, and infrastructure projects like Highway 16 are easing pressure in hot spots like Meridian and Star.

3. Cost of Living: Save Big on Housing, Taxes & Utilities

Boise’s median home price hovers around $475,000—compared to:

• LA: $1M+

• San Diego: $1.1M

• San Francisco: $1.3M+

That’s a big win for buyers. Plus, property taxes here average 0.4% to 1%—way lower than California. You’ll also save on:

• Utilities (expect $150–$250/month for gas + electric)

• Water (irrigation water is cheap)

• Home insurance (wildfire premiums are minimal here)

4. Crime & Safety: A Clear Win for Idaho

Boise’s violent crime rate is less than half the national average. Cities like Meridian, Eagle, and Star have some of the highest safety ratings in the country. If safety matters, you’ll likely breathe easier here.

5. Taxes: Flat, Simple, and Lower

• Income Tax: Flat 5.8% (vs. CA’s 6–13.3%)

• Sales Tax: 6% (includes groceries)

• Property Tax: 0.4–1% average, plus a $125K homeowner exemption

California’s tax burdens—especially for small business owners—don’t exist here.

6. Political Climate: Very Conservative (With a Blue Dot)

Let’s be honest: Idaho leans red. Conservative values, gun rights, and individual freedoms run strong.

Boise is the exception—a more liberal “blue dot” in a sea of red. It has progressive policies, visible pride displays, and a Democratic mayor. But outside of Boise, Idaho’s culture is traditional, family-oriented, and highly engaged in local politics.

7. Gun Culture: Normalized and Respected

Idaho is a constitutional carry state. You can conceal or open carry without a permit. Gun ownership is widespread, and it's culturally accepted—even expected. That said, you don’t see people walking around with rifles at the grocery store. Gun ownership here is practical and often tied to hunting.

8. Outdoor Lifestyle: It’s a Way of Life

Hunting, hiking, fishing, river floating, skiing—Idaho is built for outdoor living. Locals embrace the seasons, and nature is part of daily life. If you love being outside and want your kids to grow up that way, you’ll love it here.

9. Business Culture: Small Business Friendly

Want to launch an LLC? You can do it for under $150 in Idaho—no $800/year fee like in California. I’ve personally set up multiple businesses here. Contractors can get licensed for around $50. It’s just easier, faster, and less expensive to operate a business here.

10. Weather: All Four Seasons (With Inversions)

If you’re leaving SoCal weather, brace yourself:

• Summer: 90s–100s, dry heat

• Fall: Crisp and colorful

• Winter: Snow, 20s–30s, and occasional deep freezes

• Spring: Unpredictable but beautiful

Inversions (clouds trapped in the valley) can make winter feel gloomy. A sunny trip in January helps!

11. Culture Shock: It’s Real

From slower customer service to fewer big-name restaurants and entertainment options, life in Idaho moves at a different pace. Many love the change. Others miss the convenience of California.

And yes—people here love their state. You’ll see “Don’t California My Idaho” bumper stickers. It’s not personal, but it’s a reminder: fit matters. Idaho isn't trying to become the next California.

So... Is Idaho Right for You?

✅ Idaho is for you if you want:

• Lower cost of living

• Safety and family-friendly communities

• Conservative culture and freedoms

• Space to grow, play, and explore

❌ Idaho might not be for you if you:

• Need year-round warm weather

• Prefer city conveniences and fast pace

• Lean strongly liberal and want to influence change

• Struggle with cultural differences or seasonal shifts

Ready to Make the Move? I Can Help.

I moved from San Diego to Boise with my wife and three kids—and we never looked back. I’ve helped hundreds of families do the same.

Whether you’re just exploring or ready to buy, I’d love to help you map out the process and make sure you land in a community that fits your lifestyle.

📞 Call or Text: 208-510-0427
📧 Email: info@chismteam.com
📥 Ready to relocate remotely? Download our Boise Relocation Guide